HIV and military fitness: how to have your classification reviewed
A guide for people living with HIV who are in Russia’s military reserve: fitness classifications, medical records, applications and appeals.
Contents
If you have HIV and your Russian military ID lists fitness category А or Б, that classification can be reviewed. This is especially relevant if you are concerned about mobilisation.
But going to a military enlistment office without understanding the situation first may not feel like a great idea. Will your request attract unwanted attention? Will it mean more procedures? And is there any point if you have had your military ID for years?
Here is how HIV affects your classification, what you can do to have it reviewed, and what to consider before contacting the enlistment office.
What if I am being conscripted or already serving?
If you are being called up for compulsory military service: submit your medical records to the enlistment office. Your fitness is assessed under Column I during the conscription process. Confirmed HIV infection warrants category Д. You can appeal a conscription commission’s decision to the commission for your region of Russia or to a court.
If you are already serving, including following mobilisation: referral to a military medical commission (VVK) is handled through your chain of command and the military medical service. Submit a formal request for medical examination and assessment, attaching your medical records.
People already serving following mobilisation have the status of contract service members and are assessed under Column III. For HIV, the category under this column depends on the stage of the condition: category Д does not apply in every case.
A diagnosis does not automatically result in discharge: a VVK assessment and a formal discharge procedure are required. During mobilisation, category Д is a ground for discharge on health grounds, whereas category В alone does not provide such a general ground for discharge. Discuss your next steps with a lawyer who works with serving personnel.
Understanding categories and columns
Russia uses five military fitness categories. We retain the Cyrillic letters used in Russian military documents:
- А — fit for military service.
- Б — fit for military service with minor restrictions.
- В — limited fitness for military service.
- Г — temporarily unfit for military service.
- Д — unfit for military service.
The Schedule of Diseases, an annex to the Regulations on Military Medical Assessment, sets out the fitness categories applicable to different conditions.
It has three columns: I, II and III. Which one applies depends on your military registration status and the purpose of the assessment.
Confirmed HIV infection warrants category Д under Columns I and II. Under Column III, the category depends on the stage of the condition. The first step is therefore to establish which column applies to you.
Column I applies to initial military registration and conscription for compulsory military service.
Column II applies, among others, to conscripts without an officer rank and to reservists who have never served or have completed compulsory service when assessed for military registration purposes. The latter provision excludes members of the mobilisation manpower reserve, a separate reserve arrangement.
Column III applies primarily to current and former contract service members, people already serving following mobilisation, and certain other groups. Being in the reserve does not, by itself, mean that you must be assessed under this column.
Can your classification be reviewed?
Yes. You can seek a review if:
- HIV was diagnosed after your military ID was issued.
- The diagnosis was not taken into account when your category was assigned.
Should you contact the enlistment office?
This is probably the hardest question. There is no single answer.
On the one hand, a review can bring your records into line with your health status. Remember that category В does not, by itself, exempt you from mobilisation: it should not be confused with category Д.
On the other hand, contacting the enlistment office may draw additional attention to you.
There is no basis for saying that this will increase your likelihood of being called up. But in present-day Russia, it is difficult to guarantee the opposite, too.
Before starting the process, assess your risks and speak to a lawyer specialising in military registration and military medical assessments.
Places to seek advice on conscription and military service:
- School for Conscripts
- Call to Conscience
- Movement of Conscientious Objectors
- Get Lost (Idite Lesom)
- Soldiers’ Mothers of St Petersburg — in-person consultations and consultations via Microsoft Teams are temporarily suspended; conscripts and reservists can send questions through the official advice bot.
Which documents to gather
You may need:
- your passport;
- your military ID;
- a medical certificate confirming your HIV diagnosis;
- an extract from your records at the medical facility providing your care;
- documents stating the stage of HIV infection, where this is recorded in your medical records;
- test results, including laboratory HIV tests, documenting your health status that may be needed for the fitness assessment.
You can obtain certificates, medical extracts and records of the stage of HIV infection from the AIDS centre or clinic where you receive care.
How to apply and follow the process
If you decide to seek a review, here is where to start.
1. Prepare copies of your documents
Contact the medical facility where you receive HIV care and request the documents listed above. Make copies of everything. Attach copies to your application and keep the originals. Bring the originals with you if you visit the enlistment office.
2. Write your application
Explain that your military ID lists a particular fitness category and that you want it reviewed in light of your diagnosis.
Sample application
This is an English translation for reference; prepare the application for the Russian enlistment office in Russian.
To: the military commissar (name of the enlistment office and official’s full name)
From: (full name, passport details, address and telephone number)
Application for referral for a medical fitness assessment following a change in health status (or for a review of fitness classification)
I request that you consider arranging a medical assessment to determine my fitness for military service, taking into account my confirmed HIV diagnosis. I enclose medical documents confirming the diagnosis. Please inform me of the next steps and the decision taken.
Add the date, your signature and your name in full. Attach copies of your medical records.
This is an example, not a universal form ready for submission. Check whether it is suitable for your circumstances before using it.
3. Submit it with proof of receipt
Choose a method that lets you prove the enlistment office received your documents.
If submitting in person, bring a second copy and ask for it to be marked as received.
If posting the application and documents, use a declared-value letter with an inventory of contents and delivery notification (ценное письмо с описью вложения и уведомлением о вручении).
Keep a copy of the application, the inventory certified by a postal employee, your postage receipt and confirmation of delivery.
4. Find out what happens next
Once the application has been considered, ask the enlistment office what further steps are required.
You may need to attend in person, undergo a medical fitness assessment or supply additional documents.
If referred for medical tests or examinations, clarify where to go, the deadline and which records to submit afterwards.
5. Obtain the result
After the procedure, find out which category you have been assigned and how it will be recorded in your military registration documents.
Keep the documents recording the outcome. If your category has changed, ask whether your military ID needs a new entry and how to arrange this.
What to do if you face a refusal or disagree with a decision
If your documents are not accepted, your application goes unanswered or you disagree with the result:
- Keep proof that you submitted your application. Request a written response or, if an assessment has already taken place, a copy of the assessment.
- A military medical commission’s (VVK) assessment can be appealed to a higher VVK or to a court. An enlistment office’s refusal to refer you for assessment, or its failure to act, is challenged separately. Where and how to complain depends on the decision you are disputing.
- If you disagree with the assessment, you can obtain an independent military medical assessment from an appropriately licensed organisation. This does not automatically replace the VVK’s assessment.
Discuss a refusal with a specialist lawyer promptly: court claims have time limits. If you are concerned about the consequences of taking action, seek advice before proceeding.
Relevant legal documents
Before approaching the enlistment office, it is useful to read the main legal provisions (in Russian):
- Russian Government Resolution No. 565 on military medical assessment.
- Federal Law No. 53-FZ on military duty and military service.
- Article 5 of the Schedule of Diseases: HIV infection.
If you fear mobilisation, have already received a summons or do not know how to respond to a refusal, consider contacting a lawyer who specialises in military medical assessments.
Where to start
If you have HIV and your military ID lists category А or Б, you do not have to rush straight to the enlistment office. Start by finding out which category applies to your circumstances, gathering medical records and seeking legal advice.
You can then decide whether to begin the review process and how best to proceed.
The important thing is to make an informed decision. A change of category may affect your military registration status, but the procedure takes time and involves dealing with the enlistment office. Weigh the possible consequences and understand your rights before starting.
